Children should be playing, not in school

Two-year-olds should be playing, not in school



In order to make young children “school ready”, the English government is now encouragingparents to place their children in school nurseries shortly after their second birthday. But there is evidence to suggest that this policy might be poorly aligned to the developmental needs of such young children and that it contravenes their underlying human nature.

In the broader history of humanity, state-funded schooling is a very recent public strategy and is only about two centuries old in England. It arose from the industrial revolution as a process to instill the population with basic literacy and numeracy skills. Until even more recently, there was never any suggestion that a school environment was the right place in which to nurture children under five years of age.

So let’s take a step back and consider whether our hunter-gatherer heritage has really attuned infants towards such an environment during this very early stage of their development. Human beings are, at base, linguistic primates, born with brains that are highly “plastic”, which subsequently undergo a huge amount of development in interaction with the environment and, most importantly, other people.

Start up the jazz

The core human skills are rooted in communication. This requires a child to learn how to independently translate highly abstract thoughts into a complex combination of symbols which coalesce in spoken language. The psychologist Suzanne Zeedyk proposes that what happens between infants and carers in one-to-one interactions is a type of improvised symbolic “dance”, which she refers to as a “jazz duet”.

To be truly what psychologists call “intersubjective” — able to communicate our meanings to other people and to grasp their meanings in return — such interactions must be completely spontaneous. Each party — the child and the carer — must freely respond to the communications of the other. To give an analogy, as every jazz musician knows, in order to “jam”, you have to learn how to tune into the rhythms of others.


The way in which human beings naturally “boot” this system in early childhood is through spontaneous, play-based interaction

The way in which human beings naturally “boot” this system in early childhood is through spontaneous, play-based interaction with both peers and adults. From simple beginnings, the infant then becomes increasingly adept at effectively responding to the communications of others. The process of environmentally “booting” such an evolved system is not peculiar to human beings — it is also observed in other animals. For example, researchers have found that in young rats, free play activity builds neuronal connections in the amygdala and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex of the brain, which deal with emotion regulation and social skills.

Results factories

If modern zoos rightly go to great lengths to create environments that are as natural as possible for the animals they house, why do we care so little about extending this care and consideration to our own species? Politicians in would appear to be focused on a futile mission to eradicate millions of years of evolution in order to subjugate #human nature to the demands of international capitalist markets.

At the genesis of this process, which resulted in the imposition of a national curriculum for schools steeped in concepts of “employability”, Margaret Thatcher bluntly stated that: “Economics are the method; the object is to change the heart and soul.” The steady march of this philosophy is now poised at the threshold of the nursery, with the coalition’s recent requirement for a progress report on two-year-olds, and New Labour’s previous imposition of a formal assessment for five-year-olds.

For the past 35 years, successive governments have doggedly pursued the mission of “education as production of economic capital” through a state education system that has been increasingly monitored and directed by the government watchdog Ofsted, with its focus on data generated from standard assessments such as GCSEs. While each successive government argues that it has raised achievement, this is a spurious premise.

What they have in fact done is drive teachers into programming children towards specific test responses, in order to artificially raise achievement data. The current government now wishes to extend this process into the very earliest stages of childhood.

At the same time, 


other nations have made far greater recent gains in literacy performance in the mid-teenage years.

other nations have made far greater recent gains in literacy performance in the mid-teenage years. The 2009 results for the #Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s program for international student assessments found that #Shanghai China, Korea and Finland were the best performing nations in terms of literacy. There are vast cultural differences between these nations, but they do have one feature in common — a school entry age of seven. The nations directly below them, but above the UK, have a school entry age of six.

Kids in a cage?

Internationally renowned psychologist Alison Gopnik’s research shows that direct teaching at an early stage in a child’s development:

Leads children to narrow in, and to consider just the specific information a teacher provides. Without a teacher present, children look for a much wider range of information and consider a greater range of options.

Schooling infants is therefore commensurate with placing a young animal in a cage. Human beings evolved in a niche in which the requirement to learn how to engage in complex spontaneous interaction is paramount. Taking short cuts in early childhood in pursuit of processing human beings into units of human capital as quickly as possible risks the production of “damaged goods”.

The question for the English government should not be how to find funds to build more schools and put more teachers into more classrooms to deal with an increasing number of ever-younger pupils. Instead, it should be about supporting families and local communities to care for and educate young children within environments that are most appropriate to their biologically evolved needs.

#dq, #england

The government is expanding its growth investment programme

The government is expanding its growth investment programme

The government has announced plans to expand the Growth Deals programme with an extra £1 billion of investment in local economies

The Growth Deals programme combines all the funding provided by the government to England’s 39 Local Enterprise Partnerships (LEPs) – including allowances for infrastructure, housing and social improvement – into one single lump sum, thus giving each LEP more control over where they invest their funding.

The LEPs operation has been a great success since its inception in 2011. and local authorities in Greater Birmingham and Solihull, Greater Manchester, Leeds City Region, North Eastern, Sheffield City Region, and West of were the first to get ‘city deals’ in 2012, while Growth Deals were first announced in July last year.

It is believed that the devolution of powers and amalgamation of funding provided to LEPs will help them to target the areas that require the most attention, and thus help not only the local community, but also the country’s economy as a whole.

Giving local communities the power and the money to unlock growth and development and make the spending decisions that work for them is a key part of our long-term economic plan to secure a brighter future for Britain and ensure a recovery for all,” said Prime Minister .

“That’s what Growth Deals are all about, backing local people and investing in the infrastructure, housing and skills that will drive forward local economies, create more jobs and opportunities for hardworking people and supercharge all parts of our country.”

A number of projects have already been announced, many of which will benefit businesses: Greater Birmingham and Solihull are investing £8.7 million in training facilities to tackle the skills shortages problem; A total of £25 million has been raised to fund the creation of a National Maritime Systems Centre of Excellence in Portsmouth, which will improve the nation’s maritime capabilities and exports; Nottingham University will develop a £5 million Institute for Advanced Manufacturing.

The government predicts that over 400,000 jobs could be created, according to the Growth Deals interactive map.

“This expansion of Growth Deals with another £1 billion of projects is very welcome and a further vote of confidence in LEPs and in the importance of local decisions setting the priorities for #economic growth,” said Alex Pratt, Chair of the LEP Network Management Board. “The partnership of local business and local authorities continues to strengthen as more responsibilities are passed to them and LEPs remain focused on delivering these projects for the benefit of local communities.”

Businesses will also benefit from proposed investment in housing, broadband and infrastructure as jobs are created, travel is improved and internet access becomes faster and more reliable.

February 2015

#business, #david-cameron, #england, #member-of-parliament, #united-kingdom